Atlanta United (4-3-3): Jayden Hibbert (42), Ronald Hernandez (2), Stian Gregersen (5), Enea Mihaj (4), Pedro Amador (18), Steven Alzate (7), Miguel Almirón (10), Tristan Muyumba (8), Saba Lobzhanidze (9), Jamal Thiare (14), Luke Brennan (20)
Columbus Crew (4-4-2): Patrick Schulte (28), Marcelo Herrera (2), Steven Moreira (31), Yevgen Cheberko (21), Malte Amundsen (18), Dániel Gazdag (8), Dylan Chambost (7), Darlington Nagbe (6), Max Arfsten (27), Wessam Abou Ali (9), Diego Rossi (10)


| Thay người | |||
| 46’ | Ronald Hernandez Brooks Lennon | 42’ | Diego Rossi Hugo Picard |
| 46’ | Cooper Sanchez William James Reilly | 68’ | Wessam Abou Ali Ibrahim Aliyu |
| 46’ | Luke Brennan Juan Berrocal | 82’ | Max Arfsten Tristan Brown |
| 72’ | Tristan Muyumba Aleksey Miranchuk | 83’ | Daniel Gazdag Taha Habroune |
| 74’ | Will Reilly Cooper Sanchez | ||
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Brad Guzan | Evan Bush | ||
Brooks Lennon | Amar Sejdic | ||
Nykolas Sessock | Derrick Jones | ||
Cooper Sanchez | Jacen Russell-Rowe | ||
Leonardo Frugis Afonso | Taha Habroune | ||
Aleksey Miranchuk | Ibrahim Aliyu | ||
Cayman Togashi | Tristan Brown | ||
William James Reilly | Cesar Ruvalcaba | ||
Juan Berrocal | Hugo Picard | ||