Columbus Crew (4-4-2): Patrick Schulte (28), Marcelo Herrera (2), Steven Moreira (31), Rudy Camacho (4), Malte Amundsen (18), Taha Habroune (16), Sean Zawadzki (25), Amar Sejdic (14), Max Arfsten (27), Diego Rossi (10), Wessam Abou Ali (9)
Chicago Fire (3-4-3): Chris Brady (1), Jack Elliott (3), Joel Waterman (16), Mbekezeli Mbokazi (4), Leonardo Barroso (2), Anton Jonsson Saletros (6), Mauricio Pineda (22), Maren Haile-Selassie (7), Philip Zinckernagel (11), Chris Mueller (8), Jonathan Bamba (19)

Columbus Crew
4-4-2
28
Patrick Schulte
2
Marcelo Herrera
31
Steven Moreira
4
Rudy Camacho
18
Malte Amundsen
16
Taha Habroune
25
Sean Zawadzki
14
Amar Sejdic
27
Max Arfsten
10
Diego Rossi
9
Wessam Abou Ali
19
Jonathan Bamba
8
Chris Mueller
11
Philip Zinckernagel
7
Maren Haile-Selassie
22
Mauricio Pineda
6
Anton Jonsson Saletros
2
Leonardo Barroso
4
Mbekezeli Mbokazi
16
Joel Waterman
3
Jack Elliott
1
Chris Brady

Chicago Fire
3-4-3
| Thay người | |||
| 73’ | Amar Sejdic Hugo Picard | 28’ | Leonardo Barroso Dylan Borso |
| 54’ | Jack Elliott Dje D'avilla | ||
| 55’ | Chris Mueller Robin Lod | ||
| 90’ | Philip Zinckernagel Jason Shokalook | ||
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Nicholas Hagen | Josh Cohen | ||
Dániel Gazdag | Sergio Oregel | ||
Owen Presthus | Robin Lod | ||
Yevgen Cheberko | Dylan Borso | ||
Jamal Thiare | Christopher Cupps | ||
Tristan Brown | Jason Shokalook | ||
Cesar Ruvalcaba | Dje D'avilla | ||
Hugo Picard | Viktor Radojevic | ||
Sekou Tidiany Bangoura | Puso Dithejane | ||
Dylan Borso | |||