FC Cincinnati (3-4-1-2): Roman Celentano (18), Nick Hagglund (4), Miles Robinson (12), Teenage Hadebe (16), Ender Echenique (66), Pavel Bucha (20), Samuel Gidi (11), Yuya Kubo (7), Evander (10), Kevin Denkey (9), Brenner (8)
Columbus Crew (3-4-3): Patrick Schulte (28), Steven Moreira (31), Sean Zawadzki (25), Malte Amundsen (18), Marcelo Herrera (2), Dylan Chambost (7), Darlington Nagbe (6), Max Arfsten (27), Hugo Picard (30), Diego Rossi (10), Lassi Lappalainen (26)

FC Cincinnati
3-4-1-2
18
Roman Celentano
4
Nick Hagglund
12
Miles Robinson
16
Teenage Hadebe
66
Ender Echenique
20
Pavel Bucha
11
Samuel Gidi
7
Yuya Kubo
10
Evander
9
Kevin Denkey
8
Brenner
26
Lassi Lappalainen
10
Diego Rossi
30
Hugo Picard
27
Max Arfsten
6
Darlington Nagbe
7
Dylan Chambost
2
Marcelo Herrera
18
Malte Amundsen
25
Sean Zawadzki
31
Steven Moreira
28
Patrick Schulte

Columbus Crew
3-4-3
| Thay người | |||
| 70’ | Yuya Kubo Alvas Powell | 61’ | Lassi Lappalainen Dániel Gazdag |
| 82’ | Ender Echenique Obinna Nwobodo | 75’ | Dylan Chambost Taha Habroune |
| 90’ | Brenner da Silva Kei Kamara | 76’ | Diego Rossi Jacen Russell-Rowe |
| 90’ | Kevin Denkey Brian Anunga | 89’ | Marcelo Herrera Ibrahim Aliyu |
| 90’ | Nick Hagglund Gilberto Flores | 89’ | Malte Amundsen Yevgen Cheberko |
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Evan Louro | Evan Bush | ||
Kei Kamara | Amar Sejdic | ||
Alvas Powell | Rudy Camacho | ||
Obinna Nwobodo | Jacen Russell-Rowe | ||
Brian Anunga | Dániel Gazdag | ||
Gerardo Valenzuela | Taha Habroune | ||
Luca Orellano | Ibrahim Aliyu | ||
Dominik Marczuk | Yevgen Cheberko | ||
Gilberto Flores | Cesar Ruvalcaba | ||