New York City FC (4-3-3): Matt Freese (49), Tayvon Gray (24), Thiago Martins (13), Kai Trewin (5), Kevin O'Toole (22), Aiden O'Neill (21), Maxi Moralez (10), Keaton Parks (55), Agustin Ojeda (26), Nicolás Fernández Mercau (7), Hannes Wolf (17)
Orlando City (4-4-2): Maxime Crépeau (71), Maxime Crépeau (71), Griffin Dorsey (24), David Brekalo (4), Nolan Miller (21), Tahir Reid-Brown (29), Marco Pašalić (87), Braian Ojeda (8), Luis Otavio (5), Ivan Angulo (77), Martin Ojeda (10), Tyrese Spicer (14)

New York City FC
4-3-3
49
Matt Freese
24
Tayvon Gray
13
Thiago Martins
5
Kai Trewin
22
Kevin O'Toole
21
Aiden O'Neill
10
Maxi Moralez
55
Keaton Parks
26
Agustin Ojeda
7
Nicolás Fernández Mercau
17
Hannes Wolf
14
Tyrese Spicer
10
Martin Ojeda
77
Ivan Angulo
5
Luis Otavio
8
Braian Ojeda
87
Marco Pašalić
29
Tahir Reid-Brown
21
Nolan Miller
4
David Brekalo
24
Griffin Dorsey
71
Maxime Crépeau
71
Maxime Crépeau

Orlando City
4-4-2
| Thay người | |||
| 62’ | Maxi Moralez Talles Magno | 19’ | Tyrese Spicer Javier Otero |
| 70’ | Agustin Ojeda Maximo Carrizo | 46’ | Tahir Reid-Brown Duncan McGuire |
| 71’ | Thiago Martins Strahinja Tanasijevic | 46’ | Luis Otavio Adrián Marin |
| 71’ | Keaton Parks Raul | 62’ | Martin Ojeda Eduard Atuesta |
| 86’ | Nicolas Fernandez Seymour Reid | 79’ | Marco Pasalic Tiago |
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Tomas Romero | Javier Otero | ||
Nico Cavallo | Eduard Atuesta | ||
Talles Magno | Zakaria Taifi | ||
Strahinja Tanasijevic | Duncan McGuire | ||
Maximo Carrizo | Iago | ||
Jonathan Shore | Adrián Marin | ||
Raul | Tiago | ||
Drew Baiera | Harvey Sarajian | ||
Seymour Reid | Dylan Judelson | ||