New York City FC (4-3-3): Matt Freese (49), Tayvon Gray (24), Max Murray (23), James Sands (6), Nico Cavallo (2), Jonathan Shore (32), Keaton Parks (55), Andres Perea (8), Agustin Ojeda (26), Luighi Hanri Sousa Santos (20), Bénie Traoré (9)
Philadelphia Union (4-4-2): Andre Blake (18), Francis Westfield (39), Neil Pierre (44), Nathan Harriel (26), Kai Wagner (27), Cavan Sullivan (6), Danley Jean Jacques (21), Jovan Lukic (4), Indiana Vassilev (19), Bruno Damiani (9), Milan Iloski (10)

New York City FC
4-3-3
49
Matt Freese
24
Tayvon Gray
23
Max Murray
6
James Sands
2
Nico Cavallo
32
Jonathan Shore
55
Keaton Parks
8
Andres Perea
26
Agustin Ojeda
20
Luighi Hanri Sousa Santos
9
Bénie Traoré
10
Milan Iloski
9
Bruno Damiani
19
Indiana Vassilev
4
Jovan Lukic
21
Danley Jean Jacques
6
Cavan Sullivan
27
Kai Wagner
26
Nathan Harriel
44
Neil Pierre
39
Francis Westfield
18
Andre Blake

Philadelphia Union
4-4-2
| Thay người | |||
| 60’ | Jonathan Shore Maximo Carrizo | 62’ | Jovan Lukic Jesus Bueno |
| 60’ | Keaton Parks Kevin O'Toole | 70’ | Indiana Vassilev Quinn Sullivan |
| 80’ | Cavan Sullivan Alejandro Bedoya | ||
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Talles Magno Bacelar Martins | Ezekiel Alladoh | ||
Maximo Carrizo | Agustín Anello | ||
Mitja Ilenic | Alejandro Bedoya | ||
Malachi Jones | Benjamin Bender | ||
Kevin O'Toole | Jesus Bueno | ||
Raul Gustavo | Quinn Sullivan | ||
Kevin Pierre | Jeremy Rafanello | ||
Tomas Romero | Andrew Rick | ||
El Hadji Samb | Japhet Sery | ||