New York Red Bulls (4-4-2): Anthony Marcucci (1), Dylan Nealis (12), Noah Eile (3), Tim Parker (26), Marcelo Morales (14), Wikelman Carmona (19), Daniel Edelman (75), Peter Stroud (8), Andy Rojas (70), Wiktor Bogacz (7), Julian Hall (16)
FC Juarez (3-2-4-1): Sebastián Jurado (1), Moises Mosquera (3), Jesus Murillo (2), Alejandro Mayorga (4), Denzell Garcia (5), Homer Martinez (18), Madson (9), Guilherme Castilho (8), Ricardinho (21), José Luis Rodríguez (11), Óscar Estupiñán (19)

New York Red Bulls
4-4-2
1
Anthony Marcucci
12
Dylan Nealis
3
Noah Eile
26
Tim Parker
14
Marcelo Morales
19
Wikelman Carmona
75
Daniel Edelman
8
Peter Stroud
70
Andy Rojas
7
Wiktor Bogacz
16
Julian Hall
19
Óscar Estupiñán
11
José Luis Rodríguez
21
Ricardinho
8
Guilherme Castilho
9
Madson
18
Homer Martinez
5
Denzell Garcia
4
Alejandro Mayorga
2
Jesus Murillo
3
Moises Mosquera
1
Sebastián Jurado

FC Juarez
3-2-4-1
| Thay người | |||
| 60’ | Daniel Edelman Emil Forsberg | 33’ | Jesus Murillo Jose Garcia |
| 60’ | Andy Rojas Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting | 55’ | Jose Luis Rodriguez Raymundo Fulgencio |
| 61’ | Wikelman Carmona Mohammed Sofo | 55’ | Guilherme Castilho Rodolfo Pizarro |
| 76’ | Wiktor Bogacz Adri Mehmeti | 74’ | Ricardinho Angel Zaldivar |
| 76’ | Julian Hall Serge Ngoma | 74’ | Madson Jairo Torres |
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Mohammed Sofo | Benny Diaz | ||
Adri Mehmeti | Guillermo Ruiz Ortiz | ||
Emil Forsberg | Angel Zaldivar | ||
Dennis Gjengaar | Dieter Villalpando | ||
Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting | Jose Garcia | ||
Alexander Hack | Francisco Nevarez | ||
Serge Ngoma | Raymundo Fulgencio | ||
Sean Nealis | Eder Lopez | ||
Kyle Duncan | Jairo Torres | ||
Tobias Szewczyk | Diego Ochoa | ||
Raheem Edwards | Rodolfo Pizarro | ||
Aiden Stokes | Leonardo Rodriguez | ||