Philadelphia Union (4-4-2): Andre Blake (18), Francis Westfield (39), Japhet Sery (5), Olwethu Makhanya (29), Nathan Harriel (26), Agustin Anello (28), Danley Jean Jacques (21), Jovan Lukic (4), Indiana Vassilev (19), Bruno Damiani (9), Milan Iloski (10)
New York City FC (4-3-3): Matt Freese (49), Tayvon Gray (24), Thiago Martins (13), Raul (34), Kevin O'Toole (22), Aiden O'Neill (21), Keaton Parks (55), Maxi Moralez (10), Nicolás Fernández Mercau (7), Hannes Wolf (17), Agustin Ojeda (26)


| Thay người | |||
| 59’ | Francis Westfield Benjamin Bender | 74’ | Maxi Moralez Seymour Reid |
| 59’ | Agustin Anello Stas Korzeniowski | 83’ | Hannes Wolf Drew Baiera |
| 83’ | Bruno Damiani Sal Olivas | 83’ | Aiden O'Neill Kai Trewin |
| 83’ | Milan Iloski Cavan Sullivan | 89’ | Nicolas Fernandez Talles Magno |
| 90’ | Indiana Vassilev Geiner Martinez | ||
| Cầu thủ dự bị | |||
Andrew Rick | Tomas Romero | ||
Benjamin Bender | Talles Magno | ||
Jeremy Rafanello | Drew Baiera | ||
Alejandro Bedoya | Jonathan Shore | ||
Jesus Bueno | Maximo Carrizo | ||
Sal Olivas | Strahinja Tanasijevic | ||
Stas Korzeniowski | Nico Cavallo | ||
Cavan Sullivan | Seymour Reid | ||
Geiner Martinez | Kai Trewin | ||